[V] SOTM 19 - Freestyle

[Aidan]

Voting ends on the 7th. Good luck to all entries.

[ydoC]

Voted for #2, good luck everyone

[Aidan]

None of them stuck out to me this month.

[Father Justin]

Good luck to every one!!

[Xpnkrockemox]

Good luck everyone :D

[Mich-ae-l]

None of them stuck out to me this month.

Yeah, mine was **** also; but basically this.

All were 3rd grade signatures :(

OT: Voted for #3 because it looked better than #1.

[Mich-ae-l]

Bump etc.

[Ebin]

gl every1.

[Kris]

Voted for #2

[Anthoni]

It's a shame to see how few entries there are. We need more graphic makers! Don't be shy.

[Ralphypoo]

voted for anubis's sig :] #3

[I Anubis I]

They're nice, but they could be much better, Even if I say so myself.

Looking forward to Next Month's entries ;)

[Farcast]

GL all

[HighElfPriestess]

#2

[Turn Around]

Voted for #1.

[Pink]

I voted for none for these reasons

 

#1 - A little vague. It would be nicer if I actually knew who the photo was depicting, and maybe a small theme to it. (Yes I know it is freestyle) The face also just kind of sticks out, and I do not like it all that much. I'm not quite sure what you used on the edges of the face, but lose that, and I think it becomes much better.

 

#2 - Too much smudging. Take out the smudge of the arm, and the bright light.

 

#3 - I feel like you didn't do a lot to this. It seems like just a few lighting effects, and a sideways text that looks fancy. It is nice looking, but overall, I feel like it wasn't done well enough.

 

Please take this critique with open minds. No, I am not saying any of your GFX is bad, but that is just in need of help. Take the critique how you wish, but it is coming from an Ex-Professional Graphics Designer, so take it how you will.

[Mich-ae-l]

I voted for none for these reasons

 

#1 - A little vague. It would be nicer if I actually knew who the photo was depicting, and maybe a small theme to it. (Yes I know it is freestyle) The face also just kind of sticks out, and I do not like it all that much. I'm not quite sure what you used on the edges of the face, but lose that, and I think it becomes much better.

 

#2 - Too much smudging. Take out the smudge of the arm, and the bright light.

 

#3 - I feel like you didn't do a lot to this. It seems like just a few lighting effects, and a sideways text that looks fancy. It is nice looking, but overall, I feel like it wasn't done well enough.

 

Please take this critique with open minds. No, I am not saying any of your GFX is bad, but that is just in need of help. Take the critique how you wish, but it is coming from an Ex-Professional Graphics Designer, so take it how you will.

 

Yeah all of them were B-Grade tags, including mine.

I just chucked mine in there because we needed some entries.

And yes, your gfx is boss i know :]

[Greg-]

looks good

[Coz]

I voted #1 BC I will lol if that gets placed on PW forums for a whole month every time I scroll down!

 

ajajaja

[IphantasyI]

2nd is okay

[ZoT]

2nd looks alright

[Ghostlyboy69]

gl

[CorruptPure]

i like the sick doctor!

[Joey]

#2

[Tiffer]

gl