Bob I really cbf replying to every single one of your comments, but really ... I'll do it if i have to :/ lol
You talked about "every1" being able to compete in f2p. Only people who "cant" compete in p2p are those who are poor not being able to afford p2p
f2p pking = poor people = communism (used as a metaphor to emphasize my point)
(If you know anything communism, it targeted the large amounts of lower class people)
I believe clan should largely be valued on quality. That being said quality of members will determine success of a clan in f2p or p2p.
That being said not every successful f2p clan CAN be successful in p2p (no stats+bank required)
However any successful p2p clan CAN be successful in f2p (no reqs for f2p really LOL)
Who defines "skill?" P2p requires more INDIVIDUAL skills, absolutely, that PLUS all the CLAN efforts and skills. It's everything that f2p requires plus more.
While f2p requires staying together and moving as a unit, p2p requires having a good spread.
Both require good piling
Both require good tanking
P2p is more expensive
P2p needs good stats
=> P2p is harder than f2p
Why do you think most of f2p based clans never p2pd however all p2p clans f2p regularly? because most f2p clans tried p2ping once, failed epically and gave up
Nope. It takes more people to pile in f2p but it takes certain knowledge on how to proprly pile in p2p.
All you have to do is right click and join a pile in f2p
While in p2p you have to take a lot of other factors into account.
You don't die fast in p2p because 1 person can KO you. You die fast in p2p because one person can skillfuly use their weapons as an advantage.
3-4 people in p2p are far more dangerous (assuming they know what they are doing) than 3-4 people in f2p which makes f2p rely heavily on opts
Contradiction? I've been at every single war FOE has been at, which is probably more f2p ones than p2p ones (due to many declinations of p2p wars we f2p'd more)
That being said, with everything related to clanning, I believe success in p2p as much harder to achieve than in f2p and therefore weights more on a clan.