How do you judge what clan is better? Wildy vs Clan Wars, discussion

[Fayth]

I'd say both, but nobody really fullouts so Cw is losing it's importance to me

[BIGRYAN]

real clans win in both

^ The clans that disagree are the ones who need to rely on their numbers to win.

[konka]

You have to be able to compete in both.

[Yawnz]

Combination.

 

Clan Wars - Quality Wins (Majority of the time)

 

Wilderness - Numbers Wins (Roughly)

 

 

If you rape at both it means you have the numbers to steamroll and the quality to back it up.

[Kruckcrusher]

I don't picture a "Top clan" to lack in clan wars or wild.

[Stephen]

Both!

[Hi Im Taka]

The real 'best' clans... have the best topic makers...

 

Truly, this pure community, is usually based on opinion, in reality there is no way we can find a number one pure clan, due to all the "resources" pure clans have...

[Society]

Leadership, maturity, and the ability to not suck.

 

So pretty much noone

[Num Nums]

The real 'best' clans... have the best topic makers...

 

Truly, this pure community, is usually based on opinion, in reality there is no way we can find a number one pure clan, due to all the "resources" pure clans have...

 

Yeah i'm starting to come to that realization.

[Num Nums]

Clanwars is matched - The clan with the most orginisation will usually win ( this can be argued with wildy also ) or the clan with more experience

 

Wildy is not matched - So the clan that pulls more usually wins unlessed they get gwased or are outperformed

 

Also, wildy wars are based around propoganda unless theres actual video proof.

 

For example MM may call us Foeop and we may call them MMhf, but when the video of it comes out one clan will say they werent teaming or "they crashed but focused on you" just to make them look better.

 

Yeah I totally agree with what you are saying. Instead of saturday or sunday trips they should call it

propaganda trips because every clan wants to make it seem like they won and weren't smashed. Like for example

it was clear that MM got smashed on their saturday trip but on the MM topic in zybez they posted a kill count

with positive ratio. I was like WDF? That wasn't your overall ratio after saturday was over. Buts its understandable.

[Taste]

It's all opinion. People are going to judge clans on whatever they want to, usually based on what their own clan is good at.

Correctamundo

[aTommy]

Both.

[Milky]

Success is determined by consistency in both, but if I had to pick I'd probably go with wilderness.

 

Although matched clan wars fights are more fair and prove which clan is better man for man, I don't think it's supposed to be fair. When two countries go to war, they don't ask each other for matched opts. It's not meant to be fair and that's why clans who can't adapt to either the wilderness or clan wars aren't as successful.

[Fairy]

Success is determined by consistency in both, but if I had to pick I'd probably go with wilderness.

 

Although matched clan wars fights are more fair and prove which clan is better man for man, I don't think it's supposed to be fair. When two countries go to war, they don't ask each other for matched opts. It's not meant to be fair and that's why clans who can't adapt to either the wilderness or clan wars aren't as successful.

 

 

 

This is Runescape, not real life.

[aTommy]

Success is determined by consistency in both, but if I had to pick I'd probably go with wilderness.

 

Although matched clan wars fights are more fair and prove which clan is better man for man, I don't think it's supposed to be fair. When two countries go to war, they don't ask each other for matched opts. It's not meant to be fair and that's why clans who can't adapt to either the wilderness or clan wars aren't as successful.

 

 

 

This is Runescape, not real life.

 

It's called a reference. If you would think instead of look at meme pictures until you can find one to get some "laughs", then maybe you could be a little more smarter in life.

[Sudo]

Clan Wars.

[Loot]

Success is determined by consistency in both, but if I had to pick I'd probably go with wilderness.

 

Although matched clan wars fights are more fair and prove which clan is better man for man, I don't think it's supposed to be fair. When two countries go to war, they don't ask each other for matched opts. It's not meant to be fair and that's why clans who can't adapt to either the wilderness or clan wars aren't as successful.

i lol'd :teehee: couldn't have said it better myself

[-Adam-]

The clan with the least amount of trolls, but the most amount of friends is the #1 clan. Anyone can mass recruit 200 people with putting a stupid color hat on for weekend trips. However knowing each an every member while being friends with them is true best clan.

[aTommy]

It's too complicated now.

[-Toxine-]

The clan with the least amount of trolls, but the most amount of friends is the #1 clan. Anyone can mass recruit 200 people with putting a stupid color hat on for weekend trips. However knowing each an every member while being friends with them is true best clan.

god you're a ****.

 

consistency in both.

[Ayo Loki]

Clan wars shows quality in members, wildy shows quality in leadership (when and if it's close to matched opts)

[Cronic Ko]

IMO it comes down to what happens in the wild because there are no rules... and it isn't matched. But obviously nothing is wrong with being good at clan wars.

[Cronic Ko]

Clan wars shows quality in members, wildy shows quality in leadership (when and if it's close to matched opts)

Explain, because your wildy reasoning makes no sense to me.

[Tayyab-]

It's more important to win in the wilderness than in clan wars.

Wilderness trips are mandatory for clan members, majority of the events in clan wars are unofficial and usually small fun preps for practise.

[Ayo Loki]

Clan wars shows quality in members, wildy shows quality in leadership (when and if it's close to matched opts)

Explain, because your wildy reasoning makes no sense to me.

CWA is a secluded area with limited distance and terrain to make movement calls with, wilderness is very open and requires far more organization and, of course, a leader to call these organized movements. I don't mean to offend you, but I doubt any leaders, except the ranks of FOE, know anything about what I'm talking about.